Pizza restaurants

New England Pizza House #1

4.0 277 reviews 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM 187 W Main St, Hyannis, MA 02601, United States

Discover this place

New England Pizza House #1, located in the heart of Hyannis, Massachusetts, is a celebrated gem among pizza enthusiasts. Many customers, including the long-time patron Joseph Mendes, rave about the restaurant's unique crust—crispy yet chewy—paired with a perfect blend of top-quality cheeses. This consistency in delivering excellent pizza for over 30 years has solidified its place as a local favorite.

Maria Donadio highlights the team’s commitment to service, noting their friendliness and professionalism in accommodating special requests. The owner, recognized as a master pizza chef, consistently maintains high standards, focusing on freshness and quality. Levent T suggests trying their meat lovers and artichoke pizzas, which have garnered praise for their robust flavors.

Moreover, Lee Anne Sullivan mentions not only the pizzas but also the delightful grinders that leave customers craving for more. Pricing is reasonable, making it an ideal spot for both casual dinners and special gatherings. The restaurant's inviting ambiance and warm service enhance the overall dining experience, making New England Pizza House #1 a must-visit for anyone looking for exceptional pizza and a satisfying meal in Cape Cod.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with New England Pizza House #1 before visiting.

Reviews for New England Pizza House #1

4.0

277 reviews

100%

35%

11%

29%

Review highlights

Based on 277 reviews

New England Pizza House #1 is widely recognized for its consistently high-quality pizzas, praised for their perfect crust texture that balances crunchiness and chewiness along with a rich blend of cheeses. The restaurant has built a loyal customer base over several decades, reflecting sustained excellence in both food quality and service. Reviews frequently highlight the use of fresh ingredients, prompt hot service, and friendly, accommodating staff who are attentive to customer preferences. Patrons also appreciate the reasonable pricing and the variety of menu options beyond pizza, including popular subs and grinders. The owner’s hands-on involvement in maintaining quality is often noted, contributing to a welcoming and professional atmosphere. Overall, New England Pizza House #1 is seen as a reliable local favorite delivering classic New England-style pizza with an emphasis on tradition and customer satisfaction.

Joseph Mendes

May 01, 2025

They make a great pie! Awesome crust that is a lil crunchy AND chewy with the perfect blend of top cheeses. I've been going there for 30 years and it's still great!

maria donadio

May 01, 2025

Best pizza I have eaten in a while. The staff went out of their way to encompass my requests and nailed it. Very friendly and professional. Just try it, get the pizza.

Levent T

Apr 25, 2025

Owner is the best pizza chef but not the son in low Years and years quality never changed Suggest meat lover pizza and artichoke pizza

Travis Dolby

Apr 10, 2025

Been going here for over 30 years, best pizza and subs around

Lee anne Sullivan

Apr 08, 2025

Always fresh ingredients....served hot! Great friendly service. Excellent prices. Best pizzas! And other wonderful dishes. Grinders to die for!

Nitant Joshi

Mar 31, 2025

I’ve been to Italy and this was the best pizza I’ve ever had. I got the large Greek Pizza, service was quick and workers were kind.